Strategists in Human Capital!
Affinity International Consulting presents Futurepoint

Monday, May 26, 2014

Unwanted social media comments could render employers liable for unlawful harassment!

The case of Otomewo v Carphone Warehouse Ltd, ET/2330554/2011 demonstrates that employers may be liable for unlawful harassment under the Equality Act 2010 if employees bully a colleague because of a protected characteristic on social media.

In the case of Otomewo v Carphone Warehouse Ltd, ET/2330554/2011 Mr Otomewo, who was a manager at a Carphone Warehouse store, had his mobile phone taken by two employees, who posted a comment on his Facebook status update as follows: “Finally came out of the closet. I am gay and proud.”

Mr Otomewo subsequently complained about the Facebook comment and was later dismissed by Carphone Warehouse because of (unrelated) allegations of sexual harassment that had been made against him. He subsequently brought an Employment Tribunal claim for sexual orientation harassment, direct sexual orientation discrimination, direct sex discrimination, and unfair dismissal.

Mr Otomewo – who is not gay and whose colleagues knew he was not gay – gave evidence at the Employment Tribunal merits hearing that he had been “embarrassed” and “distressed” by the Facebook comment as it could be seen by his family and friends. The Tribunal, in its Judgment, described the actions of Mr Otomewo’s colleagues as an “unnecessary and unwarranted intrusion into his private life on public space”.

The Employment Tribunal found that Mr Otomewo had been harassed on the grounds of his sexual orientation harassment as he had been subjected to unwanted comments related to sexual orientation which had (the Employment Tribunal accepted) the effect of humiliating him. Following on from the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Edwards v Thomas Sanderson Blinds Limited [2009] IRLR 206 CA, protection from harassment extended to persons who were not, and were not believed to be, of a particular sexual orientation where the vehicle for bullying that person was sexual orientation as the purpose of the relevant legislation was to protect persons being harassed on the grounds of sexual orientation (whether this was imaginary or not).

The Tribunal also found that Carphone Warehouse were liable for the harassing actions of Mr Otomewo’s colleagues as Facebook status comment had been made by his colleagues in the course of their employment (as it had taken place at work, during working hours, and involved Carphone Warehouse’s management staff).


The case of Otomewo v Carphone Warehouse Ltd, ET/2330554/2011 shows that employers can be liable for acts of unlawful harassment under the Equality Act 2010 by their employees on Facebook or other social media (if that harassment relates to another employee, and is communicated at work during work hours). Although policing employees’ use of social media at work may seem to be a potentially administratively burdensome for employers, employers can protect themselves from liability for harassment through a “s.109 defence” – by implementing social media and equality policies at work, and training their employees in those policies. Employers should also take swift action to investigate any complaints of harassment that are made in the workplace and to produce quick and fair outcomes to these (as employers risk potential constructive dismissal claims if they fail to do so).

Summary and recommendations:

Sexual orientation harassment can occur even if those carrying out the harassment know that the victim is not gay
Employers should ensure that they have a comprehensive and effective social media policy that makes it clear that bullying through social media could result in disciplinary action
Employers should thoroughly train their employees in their equal opportunities policies
Employers should make it clear that discrimination on the grounds of a protected characteristic (such as race, religious belief etc.) could occur even if the victim does not have the protected characteristic alleged by the perpetrator, and the perpetrator knows this

Chris Hadrill is a specialist employment solicitor at Redmans Solicitors and the creator of

No comments:

Post a Comment

Sample list of colleges, our clients have attended.

Process Overview

Continual Professional Development

We provide comprehensive continual professional development to professional associations auch as The Irish Law Society, Institute of Engineers of Ireland, The Royal Institute of the Architects of Ireland and Association of Chartered Certified Accountants and other leading professional associations.

Questions to ask Yourself

Drop us your email

In return, as a valued client, we will provide you with discount vouchers on select upcoming programmes. You will also receive advance purchase notification on "high demand" master class programmes.


Please note that we take your privacy seriously

Specialist Training

If you are a Corporate entity, SME, or a "not for profit" organisation with a specific niche training requirement, please contact us.

With our extensive national and world-wide network of training consultants, we are able to identify, source and fully arrange your training completely in line with your requirements.

Strategic Management

Strategic Management

We are very proud to deliver the only short course on strategic management available in Ireland. This course has been designed to be delivered in house and is specifically tailored for the Irish multi national IDA high value manufacturing and services sector. The programme is delivered over 20 hours as an integrated format over modules decided by the client. Strategy only works when everyone is on the same page and for this reason we offer this programme for each management forum to take advantage of this unique opportunity. It is fundamental knowledge that companies that have a strong foundation and understanding of strategy and how it shapes future sustainable success are the business units that achieve prolonged success within the greater company structure. Simply put, the business unit that talks the language of the CEO attracts the greatest interest and capital input. Success is always built on strategy. See a sample of our strategic training work.
Providing management solutions and training through consultancy contracts in operations and HR management.
Website by: Déise Design